LONDON, May 25, 2022 – 62% of FTSE 350 defined benefit scheme sponsors with a 31 December year-end recorded a pension surplus at the end of 2021, up from 39% a year earlier, according to WTW’s FTSE 350 DB pension scheme report 20221, which analyses company accounts. Nearly all (94%) saw their pension funding level improve over the course of the year.
The aggregate balance sheet position for these 89 companies changed from a £1bn deficit at the end of 2020 to a £32bn surplus at the end of 2021, with the aggregate funding level up from 99% to 106%. WTW’s analysis of market movements indicates that the aggregate position moved into surplus on 5 January 2021 and has not been back in the red since. The aggregate £32bn surplus reported at the end of 2021 is estimated to have grown to £58bn by 19 May 2022.
“Rising credit spreads have held down the pension liabilities in company accounts, which discount anticipated pension payments based on high quality corporate bond yields.”
Charles Rodgers | WTW
Charles Rodgers, head of global pension accounting at WTW, said: “Rising credit spreads have held down the pension liabilities in company accounts, which discount anticipated pension payments based on high quality corporate bond yields. Schemes with large holdings of either equities or gilts will have seen these assets outperform corporate bond-based liability measures.
“Reporting a pension surplus in your accounts does not mean you can stop paying deficit contributions: the funding targets agreed with pension trustees are typically more onerous. However, many schemes are well-funded on these bases too and caps on inflation-linked pension increases could deliver a further improvement this year. As these schemes focus on reaching their long-term objectives, such as buying out benefits with an insurance company, companies and trustees will need to negotiate whether the journey plan must involve further cash injections or whether it can rely on investment performance in the first instance.”
Around three-quarters of FTSE 350 sponsors in the analysis are estimated to have paid deficit contributions in 2021 (77%), which was virtually unchanged from 2020 (76%)2. Median deficit contributions increased slightly, from £15.3 million to £16.0 million, while aggregate payments rose from £4.4bn to £4.6bn.
The proportion of companies where deficit payments were at least equal to dividends fell from 43% in 2020 to 19% in 2021. This is still more than double the pre-pandemic level (8% in 2019), reflecting how the recovery has not been uniform across all companies. However, the proportion of companies where dividends are at least 20 times as big as deficit payments has fully recovered (38% in 2021, compared with 25% in 2019 and 34% in 2020).
Charles Rodgers said: “Deficit contributions held up well at the height of the pandemic, with far fewer companies negotiating changes than had been feared. The change in the dividend-to-deficit payment ratio reflects dividends being switched back on rather than pension contributions being switched off, though improving funding levels may also affect these numbers in future.”
The trend towards closing defined benefit plans to further accrual by existing members continued in 2021: 35% of companies reported that some employees continued to accrue defined benefit pensions, down from 39% in 2020. This figure had been 69% as recently as 2015.
Charles Rodgers said: “We may be reaching a point where this trend slows: the particular circumstances of some schemes with ongoing accrual may make them difficult to close, while rising bond yields could reduce accrual costs. The cost-of-living crisis may also stiffen opposition to closure from unions and affected employees, though some employers could argue that controlling pension spending could help make pay rises affordable for the wider workforce.”
On average, companies assumed that male scheme members aged 65 in 2021 would die aged 87.0 years, and women at 88.6 years. Disclosed life expectancies for current 65 year-olds are lower than at any point in the past decade. Charles Rodgers said: “Since the 2014 peak, reported life expectancies are down about a year for men and 17 months for women. That amounts to 3% or 4% off liabilities.”
1 155 FTSE 350 companies have defined benefit pension obligations, of which 89 have 31 December year-ends. WTW’s analysis reflects the disclosures made by these 89 companies, which together account for around 80% of FTSE350 defined benefit pension obligations. For more information, WTW’s FTSE 350 DB pension scheme report 2022 is available to download.
2 Company accounts do not routinely record deficit payments in a consistent manner. As a proxy for this, WTW deducted the cost of newly accrued benefits (measured under accounting standards) from total contributions to defined benefit schemes.
At WTW (NASDAQ: WTW), we provide data-driven, insight-led solutions in the areas of people, risk and capital. Leveraging the global view and local expertise of our colleagues serving 140 countries and markets, we help organizations sharpen their strategy, enhance organizational resilience, motivate their workforce and maximize performance. Working shoulder to shoulder with our clients, we uncover opportunities for sustainable success.
