Skip to main content
Choose your location
Select the location and the language that you prefer

main content, press tab to continue

Proxy advisory policies in 2027: ISS proposes minor updates as Glass Lewis prepares for changes

Author

Brian Myers and
Peter Kimball
November 20, 2026

Key takeaways

  • ISS is proposing limited policy changes for 2027, including a new approach to option valuation for equity plan proposals
  • ISS may explicitly incorporate AI and cybersecurity failures into its policy on board oversight
  • Glass Lewis plans to replace its single house policy with four investor perspectives beginning in September 2027
  • Glass Lewis’s 2027 house guidelines remain unchanged from 2026 ahead of its new recommendation framework

As companies prepare for the 2027 proxy season, the two major proxy advisors are taking notably different paths.

ISS has proposed a relatively limited set of policy changes for 2027, including just one compensation-related update for North American markets. Glass Lewis, meanwhile, has left its 2027 house policies unchanged but is preparing to introduce a substantially different recommendation framework beginning in September 2027.

Against a backdrop of new competition from AI-driven tools, changes to Rule 14a-8 affecting shareholder proposals, and a more adversarial regulatory environment, the relative absence of significant proposed changes from ISS is noteworthy. At the same time, Glass Lewis’s planned framework signals a potentially important change in how investors can apply different perspectives and priorities to voting recommendations.

ISS proposes limited changes for 2027

ISS published its draft policy updates on Oct. 22, 2026, for market review and comment. (Final policy updates for 2027 will be published in late November or early December.) For North American companies, only one proposed change directly relates to compensation.

Option valuation for equity plan proposals and option exchanges

ISS proposes retiring the binomial option valuation model it has used for many years and moving to the Black-Scholes methodology for U.S. and Canadian equity plan proposals and option exchanges. ISS already uses Black-Scholes for say on pay and other compensation assessments, so the change would align its approach to option valuation across proposals.

ISS also has proposed four changes outside compensation that would affect North American companies.
 

  1. 01

    Board gender diversity in Canada

    ISS proposes allowing a seven-member board to meet its 30% women directors threshold with two women rather than three. New members of the TSX Composite would also receive a two-year exemption from the 30% evaluation.

  2. 02

    U.S. bylaw and charter ratification proposals

    ISS proposes minor wording changes to its policy opposing company proposals to ratify an existing charter or bylaws when doing so would have the effect of excluding a shareholder proposal seeking changes to those documents.

  3. 03

    AI and cybersecurity oversight

    ISS proposes expressly incorporating extraordinary failures of oversight involving artificial intelligence and cybersecurity risks into its existing policy addressing egregious and material oversight failures.

  4. 04

    Climate accountability

    ISS proposes moving to a case-by-case assessment of certain companies with significant greenhouse gas emissions, replacing the existing approach under which it recommends against certain directors when companies do not take at least minimal steps to assess and mitigate climate risks.

For compensation committees, the immediate policy changes are relatively modest. But ISS’s recent investor survey points to several other executive compensation issues worth watching.

For 2027 and beyond: ISS investor survey highlights issues to watch

ISS released the results of its annual policy survey in September. While the findings are distinct from its proposed 2027 policy changes, they provide useful context around investor views on several executive compensation topics.

Among investors, survey respondents:

  • Preferred voting against either the full compensation committee or the committee chair when there is no say-on-pay proposal in the U.S. and Canada
  • Supported maintaining ISS’s existing say-on-pay responsiveness thresholds of 70% in the U.S. and 80% in Canada
  • Favored evaluating on a case-by-case basis companies’ decisions not to provide prospective disclosure of long-term incentive performance goals when they believe disclosure could cause competitive harm
  • Continued to see discretionary bonus programs at financial services companies as a concern, while indicating that detailed disclosure around those decisions could mitigate concerns

These findings do not represent new ISS policies. They do, however, provide companies with additional insight into investor perspectives on compensation practices and disclosure issues that remain under scrutiny.

Glass Lewis is preparing a more fundamental shift

While ISS is proposing relatively modest changes, Glass Lewis is preparing for a more substantial evolution of its recommendation framework.

Beginning in September 2027, Glass Lewis expects to move from a single “house” policy to four semi-custom perspectives available to investor clients that don’t already use a fully customized solution. The approach is intended to support varying investor perspectives and priorities while maintaining a consistent foundation.

The four perspectives span a continuum from greater flexibility based on company performance to greater emphasis on longer-term sustainability considerations.
 

  • Business fundamentals

    The most performance-oriented and flexible perspective. Strong company performance may provide greater latitude when governance practices don’t conform to traditional best practices, with governance considered in the context of demonstrated shareholder returns.

  • Foundational governance

    This perspective gives greater weight to traditional corporate governance standards as protections for long-term shareholder value. Strong financial performance is less likely to outweigh concerns about governance structures or practices. 

  • Global stewardship

    The perspective most similar to Glass Lewis’s current benchmark policy. It combines core governance expectations with greater emphasis on financially material sustainability risks that could affect long-term financial performance and shareholder value. 

  • Sustainability focused

    The broadest and longest-term perspective considers sustainability risks that are, or could become, financially material over longer time horizons and across an investor’s portfolio, including risks related to the stability and integrity of markets themselves. 

The significance of the new framework is not a change to one specific voting policy, but the introduction of a wider range of perspectives through which Glass Lewis clients can receive voting recommendations.

What companies should watch now

For the 2027 proxy season itself, Glass Lewis has published its final house policy guidelines with no changes from its 2026 policies. Those guidelines will remain in place for the 2027 proxy season before the new recommendation framework is expected to launch in September.

Taken together, the developments suggest more continuity than disruption in the 2027 proxy season, particularly from an executive compensation perspective. The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission’s proposed overhaul of its executive compensation rules would not take effect until 2028 at the earliest, although a separate rulemaking on filer status — which would exempt many companies from compensation disclosure requirements — could conceivably take effect before the 2027 proxy season. We expect the 2028 proxy season to look very different, in terms of both disclosure by companies and evaluation by proxy advisors and institutional investors. 

ISS is expected to publish its formal 2027 policy guidelines between mid-November and early December 2026. 

PARTNER

Take your executive pay programs to the next level

See how our services and solutions can solve your toughest executive pay and board challenges.

Authors

Brian Myers

Brian Myers

Governance Team Lead, North America & Director, Executive Compensation and Board Advisory (Arlington)

Photo of Peter Kimball

Peter Kimball

Senior Director, Executive Compensation and Board Advisory